Wednesday, June 9, 2010

Sedona Lace's Brush Set vs. Sigma's Brush Set


Hey guys! I was recently sent a set of brushes to review from Sedona Lace Cosmetics. Upon receiving them I noticed immediately how similar they were to the set from Sigma. And since Sigma is fairly well known I thought I would do a comparison between the two. As you'll see not every brush is identical but the quality is the same. So if you are looking for good brushes for a bit less than Sigma check out Sedona Lace here. For the 12 brush set (without the brush roll) Sigma charges $69.00. Sedona Lace charges $49.95 for their 12 piece set which includes a brush roll.
In the pictures below the Sigma brush is on the left and the Sedona Lace brush is on the right. You can also click on the pictures to enlarge them.















Powder Brush
As you can see from the picture these two brushes are nearly identical. Bristle length and density is very similar. The shape may appear different but I attribute that to the Sedona Lace brush being fresh from the brush roll. Both brushes when washed did bleed and shed a bit which is fairly normal and expected. I really like these for applying a setting powder over foundation.














Duo Fibre Brush
Again these two look fairly similar. The only differences I can pick up would be that the Sigma brush is slightly denser than the Sedona Lace one and that the Sigma has a slightly larger ferrel. I also experienced bleeding when I washed both of these brushes, but the Sedona Lace bled a little less. This is my go to brush for applying liquid foundation.















Angled Contour Brush
I would have to say these two are nearly identical. The only thing was that the Sedona Lace brush was VERY slighty less dense, and by VERY I mean VERY. I use this brush to apply blush and contour powders.
















Foundation Brush
These two brushes are identical. I like using these style brushes to apply moisturizer especially if I am working on someone else's face.














Concealer Brush
Again no words, these are identical. I do like these brushes for appyling concealer to the face, but nothing works like your ring finger for applying it to you undereye area.

















Pencil Brush
These two are definitely different. As you can see the Sigma's ferrel is slightly wider. The Sedona Lace brush is more tapered which makes it easier to work with. I mainly use these brushes for defining my crease and blending in small areas.
















Tapered Blending Brush
And here we have the two brushes that are the most different. This Sigma brush is quite popular but I never reach for it. I tend to prefer looser, softer brushes for blending out color. Which is why I like the Sedona Lace brush. It's fluffier and works very well at softening lines.


















Eye Shader Brush
This is one of my favorite brushes to use for packing on color and I can't see the difference between the Sigma and the Sedona Lace. Again to me these look identical.




















Large Shader Brush
This is another brush where the similarities are evident. The Sedona Lace brush is wider and the brush hairs are longer. But in all honesty they work the same. I like these brushes for applying a wash of color to the lid.




















Medium Angled Shader Brush
These two are different as well. As you can see the Sedona Lace brush hairs are longer. I actually prefer the Sigma brush because I primarily use it for crease work and I think the Sigma does a better job at applying the color.



















Small Angle Brush
These two are super similiar. I am not a fan of this brush for eyeliner, which is what it is intended for. I think it's lines are too thick for my personal taste. But it does make an excellent brush for more artistic stuff, linework, detail etc.


















Eyeliner Brush
Again I am not a fan of this brush for eyeliner. I do however LOVE it for lips. I use it all the time when I'm going for a precise lip application. And as you can tell from the picture these two brushes are identical, well minus the Sigma one is a tad stained from lip products (namely the OCC Lip Tars).

12 comments:

  1. ohhh, i would love this set of brushes from sedona lace! :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for the comparison pictures. I was looking at the Sigma brushes.. i guess now i have more options.

    I'm following.. great stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for doing this review. How is the quality of the bristles? Are they really soft? In terms of softness and density, are they comparable to Sigma, or even MAC? Please let us know.

    Thanks!

    x
    Rica

    ReplyDelete
  4. @Rica The quality is on par with Sigma. I don't think they are comparable to MAC brushes however. They are very soft and the density is great.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This was a great post! I'm always so cautious when purchasing brushes, I hate spending money on something and then getting little hairs all over my face. It's just so itchy! I've been considering buy the Sedona Lace brush set for awhile now, and I think I'm ready to buy. So far, none of your reviews have steered me wrong 8^D

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for the review! I dig the pink handles, I can't help it. They look decent quality for a well rounded set. I might actually get real brushes!

    Btw, just for clarity's sake the metal tube that holds the hairs to the handle on a brush is called a "ferrule". It's another of those technical terms that are easily misspelled like the word "palette" often is.

    Again loving the Halloween windup!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Which would you recommend, sigma or sedona lace?

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks! I just ordered the Sedona Lace set and saved half the cost and shipping!

    ReplyDelete
  9. I really wish I read this earlier. I made the mistake of buying a Sigma set only to find they were almost EXACTLY the same as the Sedona Lace set I already had! I guess Sigma just has better marketing, but I agree with you the brushes are the same quality.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Wow, The sigma set used to be $69? They have DOUBLED their price because it's now $139. That's just ridiculous. Wow. Can't even wrap my head around that lol.

    ReplyDelete